naturalism vs realism

Sushi Authors

3 min read

·

14-10-2024

120

0

Share

Naturalism vs. Realism: Unraveling the Nuances of Literary Representation

In the vast tapestry of literary theory, two terms often interweave and sometimes blur: naturalism and realism. While both strive to portray the world authentically, they employ distinct approaches and focus on different aspects of human experience. This article delves into the key differences between these literary movements, drawing on insights from academia.edu and providing a clearer understanding of their impact on storytelling.

What is Realism?

Realism, as described by Professor Michael Schmidt in his work on "Realism and the Novel" on academia.edu, emphasizes the depiction of everyday life, characters, and social issues in a manner that mirrors the perceived "real" world. Realist authors aim to present a truthful and objective account of reality, often focusing on the middle and lower classes, exploring their struggles and triumphs.

Key Characteristics of Realism:

• Emphasis on Verisimilitude: Realistic novels strive for a sense of truthfulness and believability, often using detailed descriptions and accurate portrayal of settings and characters.
• Focus on Social Issues: Realist writers often explore social injustices, economic disparities, and the impact of societal structures on individual lives.
• Ordinary Characters: Realist fiction typically features characters from diverse backgrounds, often with relatable flaws and motivations.
• Emphasis on Psychological Depth: Realist authors delve into the inner lives of their characters, exploring their thoughts, emotions, and motivations in depth.

Examples of Realist Literature:

• "Madame Bovary" by Gustave Flaubert: This classic novel delves into the complexities of a woman's life in 19th-century France, highlighting social expectations and the struggle for individual fulfillment.
• "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" by Mark Twain: Twain's masterpiece explores the realities of pre-Civil War America through the eyes of a young boy, highlighting issues of race, class, and societal norms.

What is Naturalism?

Naturalism, a more extreme offshoot of realism, takes the concept of objectivity to a further level, viewing human beings as products of their environment and heredity. As Professor David Lodge explains in his article "Naturalism and the Novel" on academia.edu, naturalist authors believe that human behavior is determined by forces beyond our control, such as biology, social conditions, and the environment.

Key Characteristics of Naturalism:

• Emphasis on Determinism: Naturalism posits that human actions are predetermined by forces beyond individual control, making characters seem like pawns of fate.
• Focus on the Grim and Unpleasant: Naturalist novels often explore the darker side of human nature, focusing on poverty, violence, and social decay.
• Emphasis on the Scientific Method: Naturalism often borrows from scientific principles, attempting to portray human behavior with objectivity and detachment.
• Focus on the Lower Classes: Naturalist writers often focus on characters from marginalized backgrounds, highlighting their struggles against harsh realities.

Examples of Naturalist Literature:

• "The Red Badge of Courage" by Stephen Crane: This novel depicts the brutal realities of the Civil War, exploring the psychological and physical toll of war on a young soldier.
• "Maggie: A Girl of the Streets" by Stephen Crane: This powerful novel examines the tragic life of a young woman trapped in poverty and societal constraints.

Key Differences between Realism and Naturalism:

• Determinism: Realism acknowledges the influence of external factors but allows for individual agency. Naturalism, on the other hand, emphasizes determinism, viewing characters as products of their environment and heredity.
• Focus: Realism focuses on broader social issues and the human condition, while naturalism often explores darker themes and the brutal realities of existence.
• Tone: Realism typically maintains a more objective and detached tone, while naturalism often conveys a sense of pessimism and despair.

Conclusion:

While realism and naturalism share a commitment to portraying reality, their approaches and emphases differ significantly. Realism emphasizes the truthfulness of human experiences, focusing on social issues and relatable characters. Naturalism takes a more deterministic approach, viewing human behavior as a consequence of environmental and hereditary forces. Understanding the distinctions between these movements allows us to appreciate the nuances of literary representation and the diverse ways in which writers have explored the complexities of human life.